PalestineRemembered.com Satellite View Search Donate Contact Us النسخة العربية
Home Pictures Maps Oral History Zionist FAQ Zionist Quotes The Conflict 101 R.O.R. 101 Site Members About Us
Isn't it a fair 'population exchange' between Palestinian refugees and Jewish refugees from many Arab countries?
Post Your Comment  (11 comments

eMail
Print
כדילתרגם לעברית
Posted on March 5, 2007

Palestinian women and children leaving their homes during Nakba. Note the absence of men, most likely they were sent to labor or concentration camps

As it will be demonstrated below, this argument was concocted to deflect the discussion from the core issues of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict (the collective dispossession and ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people). It should be noted that the "Jewish state" and Zionism were created in response to the rise of anti-Semitism in Europe and not in the Middle East. Ironically, Jewish historians still associate Jewish Golden Age not in Europe, not in the United States of American, but in Arab ruled Spain (Andalusia) and Muslim Turkey

  1. It's a known fact that most, if not all, of the Arab Jews were under the direct and indirect control of the British and French occupations, who were (and still are) very sympathetic to the Zionist cause. So even if it was "true" that Arab Jews were "expelled" from their countries, this could have been easily stopped by the friendly colonial powers.

  2. Very little evidence exists that Arab populations or Arab authorities, in the various Arab nations, were involved in 'expelling' their Arab Jewish minorities. The Arab Jewish minority may had been a victim of sporadic revenge attacks (in response to Zionist atrocities perpetrated against Palestinians during the 1948 war), however, there is no proof whatsoever that this violence was organized by any group (state or non-state) whatsoever.

  3. Arab Jewish immigration occurred in stages as the "Jewish state" was able to absorb them. First priority was given to the Western/Ashkenazi Jews, whom according to Moshe Sharitt (first Israeli Foreign Minister) are considered the "....salt of the earth..."(1949, The First Israelis, p. 173), and when many preferred to go to America, they turned to Arab Jews to populate Palestine in the early 1950s and 1960s, and when that was not enough the Jewish Agency turned to the Falashas (Ethiopian Black Jews) and Russian Jews. Therefore, it should not be a surprise that early on Ben-Gurion (the first Israeli Prime Minister) made sure that the priorities of the newly founded "Jewish state" should be 'Alyah (or immigration in Hebrew) rather than peace with its Arab neighbors (Righteous Victims, p. 263).

  4. It should be noted that the vast majority of the vibrant and assimilated Turkish Jewish community immigrated to Israel despite Turkey's early recognition of the "Jewish state" in 1949. So the immigration of Jews from a friendly Muslim and Arab countries (not only from a non-Arab nation like Turkey, but also from Morocco, Tunisia, and even the Persian majority nation of Iran under the Shah before the Islamic Revolution of 1979) was being encouraged by the Jewish Agency.

  5. Ironically, the policy that encouraged Arab Jews to immigrate to Israel is still being used towards French, Argentinean, Russian, Central Asian, and American Jews. In a nutshell, this policy is governed by absorption capacity for the "Jewish state", which has always preferred Western Jews over Jews from Arab and Muslim countries.

  6. The Jewish Agency facilitated the transportation of the Arab Jews to Israel by bribing many of the local Arab and Muslim (as in the case of Iran) officials. For example, many of the Iraqi Jews were transported to the "Jewish state" via Iraqi Airways after bribing Nuri al-Said (the Iraqi PM at the time) and his wife (al-Nakba wa al-Firdous al-Mafqoud by 'Aref al-'Aref). Similarly, the Yemeni Jews were transported to Israel via friendly airlines. Ironically, the Falashas (Ethiopian Jews) were forgotten next door as their Yemeni brothers were being flown from Aden; they were picked up thirty years later (via Sudan's airports) after bribing President Numari of Sudan!

  7. When Arab Jews were hesitant to leave, Zionist gangs resorted to intimidating them by throwing bombs into their synagogues, as it was the case with the Iraqi Jews (see Related Articles section for details).

  8. As it has been the the case with Moroccan and Tunisian Jews, Arab Jews who left their counties can return back and reclaim their citizenships and properties; that is their basic human right.

  9. It is a fact that the Iraqi Government issued a plea on December 11, 1975 to its Jewish citizens living abroad to come back to Iraq. Click here to view text of the advertisement that was published in the New York Times.

  10. When many Arab authorities blocked the immigration of their Jewish citizens to Israel, the Jewish Agency and many Western embassies protested, as in the case of Syria.

  11. When so-called 'population exchanges" happen, it occurs as an agreement between two or more sovereign nations, such as in the Greek/Turkish 'exchange' agreement of 1923. On the other hand there was not and is no alleged "population exchange" agreement in the case of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict. In a nutshell, to ethnically cleanse (illegal, violent compulsory population transfer) the people of a whole nation and to replace them with settlers from another group of people cannot be called a 'population exchange', but rather a war crime.

  12. It should be noted that in the case of the Palestinian people there is a UNGA resolution 194 that calls for their return plus compensation (which has been reaffirmed by the world body over 150 times since Sept. 17th, 1948). On the other hand, there is no such resolution for Arab Jews since it is not needed to begin with because there is no Arab country that blocks the return of its Jewish citizens. Furthermore, the Palestinian people always demanded their return at all levels (individually and collectively) since 1948; and Arab Jews never call for their right of return but mostly they demand compensation. In other words, the Palestinian people demand to return even under Israeli rule, but until this date there is no organized body in the Arab Jewish community in Israel calling for their own return to their respective Arab countries.

  13. Beside the previous point, often Arab Jews react negatively when called refugees. For example, Knesset speaker Yisrael Yeshayahu declared: "We are not refugees. [Some of us] came to this country before the state was born. We had messianic aspirations." Similarly Shlomo Hillel, a government minister and an active Zionist in Iraq, adamantly opposed the analogy: "I don't regard the departure of Jews from Arab lands as that of refugees. They came here because they wanted to, as Zionists." In a Knesset hearing, Ran Cohen stated emphatically: "I have this to say: I am not a refugee." He added: "I came at the behest of Zionism, due to the pull that this land exerts, and due to the idea of redemption. Nobody is going to define me as a refugee." Click here to see the full report from the Israeli newspaper Ha'aretz.

  14. The "Jewish state" was founded by Zionists in response to European anti-Semitism, not Arab anti- Semitism. It should be emphasized that if it was not for European anti-Semitism, Jews and Palestinians would have stayed in their original home towns or countries as it had been the case for thousands of years. In other words, the "Jewish state" was founded to "save" European Jews; not the Arab Jews.

  15. According to Universal Declaration of Human Rights adopted by the UN on 10 December 1948 any person has the right to leave his/her home town and has the full right to come back to it. Such a right does not diminish over time. This is one of the basics of human rights. So any Arab Jews still have this basic inherent right.

  16. For decades, the Arab Jewish population in Israel were heavily discriminated against by the a Ashkenazi Jews, who kept them in refugee camps (Ma'baruts) living in tents for a very long time. For many, it was much easier to hire Israeli Palestinians than the Arab Jews living in Israel. It should be noted that the case of 300+ kidnapped Yemeni kids (who were later adopted by Ashkenazi families) have not been closed to this date.

Related Links

 

Post Your Comment

Posted by Webmaster on January 3, 2013 #148228

لندن ـ 'القدس العربي': انتقد عميد الصحافيين العرب الاستاذ محمد حسنين هيكل التصريحات التي ادلى بها قياديون في جماعة 'الاخوان' مؤخرا، ودعوا فيها اليهود المصريين الى العودة الى مصر، واتهموا فيها الرئيس الراحل جمال عبد الناصر بطردهم من مصر في الخمسينيات.
ووصف هيكل التصريحات بانها 'صيحة من لا يعرف في موضوع لا يعرفه، ويطلقها اناس ضائعون في ساحة القتال'.
وقال هيكل في حديث الى قناة 'سي بي سي' المصرية الخاصة 'لا يوجد على الاطلاق ما يسمى بتعويضات اليهود'.
وشرح ذلك بالقول: معظم أغنياء اليهود في مصر كانوا يحملون جنسيات أخرى، (قطاوي فرنسي، وهراري ومزراحي بريطانيون، ولم يمتلكوا جوازات سفر مصرية، وبعض اليهود رحلوا عن مصر بعد حرب فلسطين وآخرين بعد حريق القاهرة اي قبل اندلاع ثورة يوليو 1952''.
واكد ان الدولة المصرية دفعت تعويضات لكل الشركات التي اممت عام 1960 بما في الشركات اليهودية التي كانت تحمل جنسيات غربية ضمن التعويضات التي دفعت الى الشركات الاوروبية.
واشار الى ان تعداد اليهود المصــــريين في العام 1947 بلغ ستين الفا، وان الجالية اليهودية في مصر لم تعان اي اضطهاد، وان التحقيــــقات في قضــــية لافون (استخدام اليهود في شن عمليات تخريب ضد اهداف غربية في مصر عام 1954) تظهر ان الجالية اليهودية كانت من الجاليات المستقرة، ما دفع البعض في اسرائيل الى الاعتراض على تجنيد افراد منها في العمليات.
ونفى ان يكون عبد الناصر طرد اليهود من مصر، واكد ان من بقي منهم في مصر بعد الثورة 'مشوا من انفسهم بعد حرب السويس'.
واضاف هيكل، 'لم يعجبني كلام مرسي عن فلسطين، حيث لم يدنِ المستوطنات أو الحديث عن القدس في حديثه، ولا أطالب مرسي بالحرب، ولكن القدس قضية جوهرية لدى التيار الإسلامي'.

وأضاف هيكل ، 'لا بد أن نفرق بين كاتبي الخطابات والمحترفين والكتبة، وقد كتبت خطب عبد الناصر لأني كنت طرفاً محاوراً له باستمرار'.
وقال هيكل، 'إن الخطأ الأساسي للرئيس محمد مرسي، في الحكم هو عدم مصارحته بالحقيقة، وأنه لا يملك مفاتيح الحل لأزمات البلاد'، مشيراً إلى أن مرسي هو الذى طلب السلطة بالقوة. وان مصر أصبحت ريفية السياسة، والعالم العربي أصبح منعزلا في سياسته الخارجية، وان النظم العربية الموجودة حاليا متخلفة منذ الحرب الباردة ولا تتحمل عناء الدفاع عن نفسها، وأنه أصبح لدينا في العالم العربي أشخاص يتحدثون في قضايا لايعرفون عنها شيئا.
وأضاف هيكل أن جزءا من الأزمة الاقتصادية في مصر سببها خطاب الرئيس مرسي، وأن الرئيس مرسي يرى الحقيقة من قبل، ولكنه كسياسي يتخذ القرار الخطأ في الوقت الخطأ.
وفي سياق متصل، أوضح 'أن من يصنع خطاب الرئيس عليه أن يعبر عن الواقع، ويخاطب الداخل أولا ولو على حساب الخارج، وعليه أن يدرك حاجة مصر إلى خطاب جديد'، مشيرًا إلى 'أن النظام لديه إعلامه، إلا أنه لا ينافس'.
وعن الإعلام الخاص، قال هيكل إن الإعلام يزعج السلطة وتأثيره مقلق، مشيرا إلى أنه يخبر الحقيقة للاخرين، ويفتح الملفات ويبحث عن الحقائق، موضحا أن الإعلام لا يحاسب ولا يراقب، وأنه إذا كان الإعلام حرا حماه جمهوره وأخلاق المجتمع، فيما انتقد القنوات الدينية واصفا إياها بأنها قنوات ادعاء ديني لا علاقة لها بالأخلاق.
Posted by Brent on June 17, 2012 #144542

A good quote on this general topic by another writer refuting Zionist hasbara propaganda and lies; "Let us, for the sake of argument, take seriously Blumenthal's allegation that Jews were dispossessed by Arabs. If we were in a position to ask her when exactly this alleged dispossession took place, she'd say 'in the fifties'. But notice she doesn't supply this information. And there's a reason for that: if the reader were told that the dispossession of the Palestinians came first - in 1948 - he or she might legitimately conclude that the so-called dispossession of Jews from Arab countries was undertaken in revenge for the earlier dispossession of the Palestinians, and that Israel, therefore, bears primary responsibility for perpetrating such a crime. Propagandists like Blumenthal therefore tend to avoid any reference to timing and prefer to leave the reader labouring under the mistaken notion that both dispossessions - the real (Palestinian) and the alleged (Jewish) - took place simultaneously."
Posted by Brent on December 20, 2010 #127992

The Zionist "Israelis" purposefully radiated around 100,000 Sephardi Jews (mostly Sephardi Jewish children) killing many of them in this near genocide again just look up the completed documented "ringworm affair" of the Zionist "Israeli" Ashkenazi government! And "David" resolution 194 clearly calls for the return of Palestinian refugees that the Zionist Khazars ethnically cleansed out. And don't give the usual Zionist hasbara propaganda of the "big bad" UN being against you as the UN in those days was nothing but a good old boys club of white European colonialist countries which the white European Zionist Jews were a part of just like Balfour Declaration and the Rothschild Zionist bankers in Europe!
Posted by Brent on December 20, 2010 #127991

Everyone should google "ringworm affair" to look at the wicked, evil practices the Ashkenazi supremacist white European Khazar Jews in Zionist "Israeli" used against non-white groups lik the Sephardi Jews. The Zionist "Israelis" purposeful radiated around 100,000 Sephardi Jews killing many of them in this near genocide again just look up the completed documented "ringworm affair" of the Zionist "Israeli" Ashkenazi government!
Posted by David on October 20, 2010 #124029

At the time all the Arab states voted against Resolution 194, because it did not establish a “right of return,” and because it implicitly recognized Israel. It is disingenuous, at best, now for advocates of the Palestinian cause to see today in Resolution 194 the right of return that they formerly claimed did not exist.
Posted by Damien on August 27, 2009 #87484

There is a MAJOR difference between jews who left their homes in Arab countries after 1948 and the Palestinians who were forced by Israeli terrorist government and military to leave their homes and their own country. The difference is that Jews were not forced to leave, and they can go back if they want to (look how many have returned to their countries in Tunis and Morocco in the 1990s). In addition, Zionist organizations fabricated attacks on jews who lived in Arab countries so that those jews could be convinced to leave their countries. Zionists spent a lot of money to force or to convince jews in arab countries to go to newly establishes Isreal so that number of jews there can be increased... look what Zionists did to transfer Iraqi jews from 1948 to 1957 to so called Israel. Therefore, comparison between evicted and victims of Palestine with those jews who lived in Arab countries (these jews can claim their Arabic citizenship and property at any time, while Palestinians can NOT). Until when Israelis and jews will continue their denial and self-lying?!
Posted by Brent on May 27, 2009 #78329

Zionist "Israel" was and is racist. Read about the "Israeli" Black Panthers. These "Israeli" Black Panthers were 2nd generation Arab Jews living in "Israel" that in the 1970s had many rallies, riots, and fought back against Zionist forces that were trying to stop their rallies: that were simply protesting white Askhenazi racism and mistreatment of Arab Jews. Also Zionist "Israel" has been caught many times before dumping donated blood given by Ethiopian Jews living in "Israel". Clear Zionist racism!
Posted by Brent on October 27, 2007 #22428

The wealthy Zionist non-Semitic White European Ashkenazi Jews have and still hold racist views against the true Semitic Arab Jews from Iraq, Morocco, Yemen, etc. as the "dirty" working class. Much in the same way that some Republican right-wing Americans view Hispanic immigrants into southern American states like Arizona, California, etc. as unwanted lower classes. History tells us the devil white man stole what is today the southern "United States" from it's rightful Mexican owners. Just as the whites took all of America from it's rightful Native American (Shawnee, etc.) owners.
Posted by Brent on October 27, 2007 #22427

It must also be noted that these true Arab Jews, who are actually Semites unlike the WHITE European Ashkenazi Jews, have been and still are heavily discrimnated against in Zionist "Israel". The rich, upper class of "Israeli" society is almost completely WHITE European Ashkenazi Jews, mostly consisting of immigrants from Europe, America, Canada, etc. The racial hiearchy in Zionist "Israeli" society has rich, wealthy, evil non-Semitic White Ashkenazi Jews on the top of the heap.
Posted by Brent on September 14, 2007 #20416

Andy the Zionists were working hand-in-hand with the Nazis, Mussolini's facist Italy, etc. Groups like the Stern Gang (Lehi) with Avraham Stern and futured "Israeli" prime minister Yitzhak Shamir. Also Jewish org. like the United Jewish Appeal, etc. were helping send their Jewish brothers and sisters into harms way. Yitzhak Greenbaum a WWII era Jewish Zionists famously said "One Cow in Palestine is worth more than all the Jews in Europe". Another famous quote by the Zionist Jews of that era "only by blood will we get our state" referring to sending fellow Jews to die or suffer. Just see the books "51 Documents" by Lenni Brenner and "Min Hametzar" by Rabbi Weissmandl to see Zionist Jews alliances with Nazis and others to kill Jews. Also note that Jews ran the Bolshevik party and Lazar Kaganovich was a Jewish genocidal killer of 7-10 million.
Posted by Andy Dyer on July 11, 2007 #17848

Your writing is getting better (or "more acceptable to Western ears"!). Your references are better (though there's more work to do). Some of your arguments are compelling (eg Sephardim refuse to be called refugees).

The one thing you've not dealt with is the argument that Nazi ideology had taken root all over the Middle East, including Husseini. (And mention the UCHR, the Zionists quoted "everyone shall have the right to leave their country" when they wanted the Russian Jews out, but didn't mention the very next sentence "return to their country").

Photographs of sources are increasingly needed - you need your material being referenced on Wikipedia. Don't turn your nose up at it, the Zionists are very powerful there and will block anything textual from you - but they cannot do that if you've got photographs available.

However, you need to take out some of the sloppy material you've got such as "most likely they were sent to labor or concentration camps" at "Story1649"