Everyone has to know the problem is not as simple as one people pushing the other into the sea. its atrocious what the palestinians are experiencing, but one must understand the land was in in existence before 1946. We must not forget the jews were in exile from the time of the Roman empire. They were actually pushed out of the very same lands by the superpower of that era after destroying their temple, homes and villages. The land did not remain vacant after that. May people have since called it home. The best solution is a 2 state solution, with shared cities, but with the hatred and mistrust in both sides I fear that will not happen, and what we observe will continue to be normal.

IS there any plan to dub these into Enlish, or to make an English language documentary? Most Americans know nothing about this.

We are all brothers and sisters, we all have the right to live in our own land, therefore both Palestine and Israel both have the right to exist. How can these people forget that there lived side by side one day and their God is the same. Stop the fight and live in peace, before we realize we all will be dead anyway, why not enjoy and let others do too. Peace & Love to you all.

Martin: Not sanctioned by God but by foreign imposter terrorists. Palestine had no army to defend themselves either.

Every conquering horde claims to worship a god that commands them to act like demons.

I believe..."Nothing more important then the living human being", but at times forces pushes people one way or another.
I live in New York City where there are 131 or more different nationalities, everyone getting along as it seems out in the open, back room talk is another matter. There will never be peace in Israel because the Jews will not accept anyone outside their own race, they strongly believe by nature they are the chosen ones to guide and rule the world as all peoples of the world have nothing but animal brains. Jews in New York when in dislike with something use their religion as an excuse for rebellion. They say..."its against our religion", but actually they want control and making others have limited success in their lives. They bring hate to themselves where ever they go, they reject everything that isn't Jewish and demand a change. Lucky for them New Yorkers are peaceful, at this time, otherwise many would be hurt for the annoyance they erupted as this past summer with an art gallery, bike lanes, truck advertisements, and non Jewish women walking in short dresses through "THEIR" neighborhood. They are a self cast out race, refuse to intermix with anyone unless they see a benefit in dollars or control for themselves. In New York they control the politicians and only for their own gains. Recently there is a nasty saying going around targeted to the politicians only,..."The further away a politician is from the Jew, the closer he is to the people". Another back room remark is..."Don't trust a rapist with your daughter, don't trust a Jew on his dealings". Does anyone remember the Jews asking England to promise them Palestine if they can get America into the first world war to defeat Germany? Does anyone remember the Jewish boycott in America and England against buying German goods, this eventually sparked the German boycott of Jewish stores. Jews struck first declaring "Jews declare war on Nazi Germany". This was way before any violence against the Jews were started in Germany. Their loyalty was non-trusting both times preceding both wars in the eyes of the German population, how much can we (Americans) or anyone trust them. There has been a remark here in New York to the Jews to bind together to get rid of President Obama for not backing Israel to a much greater extent, just a remark now this was, in the New York Post, just as they bounded together to stage a global boycott of German goods, they can't be trusted !!! And if ever our New York mayor, Michael Bloomberg ever becomes President, enslavement will follow, America destroyed as he backs only Jewish concerns, he too (a Russian Jew) is non trusting, a swindling, lying, two face, backstabbing miss-fortune. A billionaire who finances only Jewish issues all others he has a deft ear to. You know what Jewish people, get out of America and go to your promise land and work your chosen miracles for yourselves there, too many other nations hate America, want death to America because of you, because America backs all of you we get denounced. Jews get out and stay out !!! Don't go to Europe, I've heard back room talks there also, especially in France, Poland and Russia, and in Germany, if you knew the thoughts of people, but are afraid to express themselves and can be arrested for speaking any Jewish dislike. Damned their freedom of speech in Germany !!!

Peoples of Canaan and these lands have fought over boundaries over 3000 years. The Hebrew people first came from Mesopotamia to lands of Canaan and then the sea people, known then as the Philistines, settled along the south-western coast of Canaan. These two groups are now the Israelis and Palestinians. How can it be said that Israel took the land from Palestinians...

Thank you for posting this map. I am in a dicussion with a person. about Palistine and how after WWII some outsiders saw fit to give a some of Palistien to create a new country Isreal. I agree that to take a group and give part of what they have to another group.
To me ths would be like me and some of my other neighbors go to another neighbors house and say well this family has no place to live, so, I am giving them half of your house. I really don't think my neighbor would be happy with us.

Hi,to the president of the Palestinian people.
We have to look to the future and not to the past,
because future can be for both of the peoples
but the past is relative to each ones point of view.
Israel Jordan and Palestine are old words
from the old world.
The best , on my point of view is to make one big state with all peoples
Muslims Christians and Jews.
Only that this has to be a secular state because 3 religions can work together only if they are not run by the state.
In one secular state you can have many religions
but in a religious state , only can be 1 religion and no secularism
respect is the key word for peace
and maybe call that state Abrahamia
eh?
PEACE4US
LAND 4 ALL OF US
PS:
I'm an Israeli
who is fed up of injustices

We love you Palestine. My children love you and we are soon coming to visit you. We keep you alive from generation to generation and we refuse to let you die

hi , i am an iguana my name is zilla , n i was wondering 2 things i just can't comprehend , i know the size of my brain is the size of a pea , but mayb some1 could help me understand , y is it that jews get upset and called people anti-semetic when people of any religion reject their holocust , when jews them self including the israely goverment , reject the armenian genecide which was in fact the 1sr holocust of the 20th century .
The 2nd is , y do jews cry about Germanys ethnic-cleansing , when the jews r doing the exact same thing 2 the palestinians . im not a jew or christian , as i only believe in the egg that i came out .
If another iguana tries 2 climb in2 my egg , with out my permission n by force , i should concidered that an occupation , n if i had rockets i will bomb the crap out of her till she takes her tail out of there .
thanks , tschuss .

Nor Jewish or palestinian where a Nation. To be a nation is not essential any way. Maybe in the mind of few bourgeois poeple in the end of the 19 century they where a Jewish or Palestinian nation. But is does not change anything. Arabic poeple, farmers, workers, intelectuals, where woirking on this land, blad el sham. Even if they did not call themself Palestinian people in any occasion . The zionist movement is a colonial movement that has no legitimacy to took this land what ever was the name of it.

Now the name is Palestine, and it includes the Palestinian Mandate where the zionist movement destroyed the land, the culture, the work of the indigenous people from 1900 till now. Now the Palestinian feeling and nation is real and legitimate.

I do not justify the moves of Israel since they went to Palestina's Territories, They were terrible, but im really sorry to say to all "Muslim Palestinians" that there was no "Palestina Nation" before the Jews came. First the Ottoman, then the British mandatory. So now it sounds really strange that suddenly Palestinians want to have a nation. Israel is a multicultural country, why do they not accept to live together???? My Goodness, wake up!! I really do not think that Israel is nasty and Palestinians are the "poor little babies". Palestinians just dont want to assimilate and Israel is just too arrogant and makes more troubles!!
Allah, Allah, Allah. No God is gonna help you my dear, because God knows who is honest, and I'm sure that Israel will be punished for his crimes, but Palestinians will never achieve what they want, because they do it against other cultures, They are the first to block a multicultural society, exactly like fanatic Iran's Government. And believe me, GOD knows THAT. So beware.

I AM NOT HAPPY WITH THIS MAP!:(

The state of Israel was established in Palestine and supported by the western forces as an extention to the Crusade wars Europe launched against the region in the past. In that, the Christian world is as a victim as the Muslims are today, because these wars were superficially launched in the name of Christianity while the real reason was purely political and economical (The struggle between the Church and states in Europe over power, and the poverty wide spread across Europe at that time). The Jewish people were used by Zionism to spearhead the mission. This is why whenever the Arabs fight Israel they find themselves fighting the whole world!

Therefore, there should be no surprise to find the Palestinians (and Arabs) fighting a religious war defending themselves. In my view, just as today's nations and their populations had paid and still are paying the price of powerful politicians greed. Now Europe is in poverty no more. Therefore Europe must reconsider their humanitarian responsibility towards Palestinians. Unfortunately, Europe never did and will never do such a thing, as France has just refused to apologise to Algere for their 150 years of ocupation and looked at the matter as not worthy for any apology. Such tanacity can not make anyone optimistic about the future.

Inshallah palestine came back soon

Justice will not be done until reparation is made to Palestinians for the theft of their land and possessions and they have their own independant state. Reparation should be made not just by Israel but all nations who were complicit in reducing Palestians to refugee status.

LONG LIVE PALASTINE

this is vry nice bg thanxs for thise

i cant believe how nice this map is wahit ullah !!!