Kastner Saved Lives Too: How does justifying Haavara after the fact not resemble Kastner's defense of what happened on his infamous train but at a much larger scale? Kastner too saved Live!History is often written by the victors, but financial ledgers are written by the survivors. When one compares the official history of the "Kastner Train" rescue with the forensic accounting of the assets involved, the numbers do not just fail to add up --they reveal a transaction so cynical it reshapes our understanding of the post-Holocaust era.
The story of Rezo Kastner and SS Colonel Kurt Becher is traditionally framed as a desperate moral dilemma: a Jewish leader negotiating with the devil to save lives (the same alibi used to justify signing the Haavara Agreement with Hitler in 1933). But a close examination of affidavits, inventory lists, and archival discrepancies suggests a different, darker narrative. It appears to be a story not of rescue, but of indulgence --a system where the Jewish Agency (JA) sold "a reputation cleanser" to Nazi war criminals in exchange for a cut of their stolen loot.
Kastner Saved Lives Too: How does justifying Haavara after the fact not resemble Kastner's defense of what happened on his infamous train but at a much larger scale? Kastner too saved Live!This deal, smelling of corruption from A to Z, was not an anomaly. It was likely the pilot program for the massive Reparations Agreement of 1952, setting a precedent where the "Jewish state" prioritized asset recovery over justice, allowing the "denazification" of perpetrators who paid their dues.
To understand the magnitude of this betrayal, one must first understand who Kurt Becher was. He was not a low-level bureaucrat; he was the Chief of the Economic Department of the SS Command in Hungary and was later appointed Special Commissar for all Concentration Camps. His job was literally to monetize the Holocaust --extracting maximum value from Jewish victims before their destruction. Just before Nakba, the Jewish Agency sent a representative, Rezo Kastner, to the Nuremberg Trials in 1947 to save such a man from the gallows, which is the central scandal of this story, see The Seventh Million by Tom Segev, pp. 270-271, and Wikipedia
The Discrepancies: A Deal That Doesn't Add Up
Kastner Saved Lives Too: How does justifying Haavara after the fact not resemble Kastner's defense of what happened on his infamous train but at a much larger scale? Kastner too saved Live!The official story is that Kastner testified in favor of Kurt Becher at Nuremberg because Becher had "saved Jews" and returned Jewish looted assets. However, the physical evidence tells a story of grand larceny and a cover-up.
1. The Missing Millions: 97% of the Treasure Vanished
The forensic accounting reveals a massive gap between what the passengers paid and what Becher "returned."
-
The Real Value (8.6 Million): According to the Jewish community's own records, the ransom collected for the "Kastner Train" alone was estimated at 8,600,000 Swiss Francs (over $2,000,000 USD in 1945 values), see the Golden Train by Ronald Zeig, pp. 230. Actually, Kastner estimated the value was far higher --up to 15 million Swiss Francs, see the Golden Train by Ronald Zeig, pp. 227.
-
The Affidavit Lie (2 Million): In his 1948 affidavit, Becher swore he handed over assets worth "approximately 2 million Swiss francs." He effectively erased 6.6 million francs of liability simply by under-declaring the value of what he stole.
-
The Reality ($55,000): When the Jewish Agency finally sold the contents of Becher's six suitcases in 1947, they realized only $55,000.
-
The Gap: Becher promised a fraction (2 million), but the Agency accepted pennies. The difference between the $2,000,000 collected from victims and the $55,000 recovered is the price of the indulgence. Mazletov!
A critical loophole in Kurt Becher's 1948 affidavit exposes the legal trickery used to launder the stolen assets. In Paragraph 7, Becher swears that the funds are to be used "for humanitarian purposes AS DIRECTED BY DR. KASZTNER."
3. The "Worthless Currency" Lie
Hungarian Jews were marched down Wesselenyi Street in the heart of Budapest's Jewish Quarter on their way to be deported to Auschwitz.Apologists claimed the discrepancy was due to inflation--that the suitcases contained Hungarian Pengo that became worthless. This is a historical insult.
-
The wealthy passengers on the Kastner train paid in diamonds, gold bullion, Napoleon gold coins, and platinum. Refugees do not hoard collapsing paper currency; they hoard hard assets. Most importantly, Nazis and Hungarian Jews valued the looted assets in Swiss francs!
-
Becher, an SS economic expert, would never have accepted or hoarded paper trash.
-
The only logical conclusion is that the paper money found in the suitcases was filler--props used to give the bags volume while the real assets were stripped.
4. The Timeline Black Hole
Why were most Kapos Zionist activists? Click the picture for the details.The transfer of these "assets" did not happen under American supervision. Becher handed the suitcases to Moshe Schweiger (Kasztner's deputy) on May 4, 1945, at a hunting lodge in Weissenbach. The two men spent a full week together before the American Counter-Intelligence Corps (CIC) arrived on May 12.
The "Good Nazi" Billionaire
If the deal was "humanitarian," why did the Nazi end up rich and the victims poor?
Kurt Becher did not just survive the war; he thrived. While his colleague Dieter Wisliceny was hanged, Becher returned to Bremen and became one of the wealthiest men in West Germany.
The Accusation: Shmuel Tamir and the "Split"
Fake Valor: Daddy, what did you do during the Holocaust while you were in Palestine?During the famous 1954 libel trial in Jerusalem, defense attorney Shmuel Tamir (representing Malchiel Greenwald) exposed the darkest implication of the affair: that the treasure was not "lost," but split, see The Seventh Million by Tom Segev, pp. 270-271.
Tamir argued that the relationship between Kastner (representing the Jewish Agency) and Becher did not end with the war --it evolved into a business partnership.
-
The Theory: Tamir implied that Becher kept the vast majority of the looted wealth (the missing millions) to rebuild his life in Germany. In exchange, he handed over a "settlement" portion to the Jewish Agency (the $55,000 and perhaps other unrecorded funds).
-
The Quid Pro Quo: The Jewish Agency accepted this partial payment as "Net Profit" and, in return, provided the Affidavit that saved Becher from hanging.
-
The Silence: This explains why the JA did not sue Becher for the missing millions. You do not sue your partner in a secret deal; you accept the split and keep quiet.
The Omission: Whitewashing the Jewish Agency's Role
SS men and police take away the Jewish men they have arrested in Baden, Baden. November 10, 1938How did history miss this? Because the historians protecting the Zionist narrative omitted the smoking gun.Holocaust
Yehuda Bauer, Israel's most senior Holocaust historian wrote in his definitive book Jews for Sale?, admits that Kastner testified for Becher but frames it as a personal error of an "ambitious" man. He conveniently omits the institutional link.
JTA Sept. 3rd, 1933 Quoting Nahum Sokolow: "Hitlerism enables us to convert all Jews to Zionism."Tom Segev, in The Seventh Million, published three years earlier, provides the missing piece. He quoted Kasztner’s affidavit directly:
"I make this statement not only in my name but also on behalf of the Jewish Agency and the World Jewish Congress", see pp. 270.
This single sentence destroys the "Lone Wolf" theory. Kastner was not acting on a personal whim; he was sent by the Jewish Agency (specifically the Political Department headed by Moshe Sharett) to Nuremberg. His mission was to secure the assets. If Becher hanged, the location of the loot died with him.
Contempt for the Public
David Ben-Gurion envisioned that Nazis' Nuremberg Race Laws would become the LEVER that would end up creating the "Jewish state," but how? Click the image for the details The Jewish public was furious. Survivors and the wider community viewed the defense of an SS officer as a betrayal of the dead. Yet, the Jewish Agency proceeded anyway. The fact that the leadership sent Kastner to save a man like Becher --ignoring the screams of their own constituency-- demonstrates a contempt for the Jewish public that echoes to this day. They valued the "deal" over the dignity of the survivors.
Coaching the Witness
Herzl Died Thinking Israel Would Have Been in Uganda, not in PalestineBauer’s own text inadvertently reveals the depth of the collusion. Describing an interrogation in 1947, Bauer writes that Becher "could not remember" saving Jews. Kastner then "more or less forced him to 'remember'" his humanitarian deeds
The Missing Evidence
The cover-up extended into the German justice system. In the 1960s, Swiss journalists attempted to find the "Himmler Order 17," a document proving Becher’s deep involvement in the mass murder units. The document had mysteriously disappeared from the files of the West German prosecutor. Even decades later, Becher was being protected--likely because exposing him would expose the deals made by the State of Israel, see Jews for Sale?, pp. 210-211.
The Indulgence System: A Pattern of "Useful Nazis"
Why do you think Zionist Organizations are actively promoting "I Love Hamas" Stickers? How many similar schemes were done, and we are ignorant about who was behind them?Kastner didn't just save Becher. He also testified for SS General Hans Jüttner.
-
The Lie: Kastner claimed Jüttner "took pity" on Jews and stopped a death march.
-
The Truth: The march stopped because retreating German troops blocked the roads.
-
The Motive: Becher’s affidavit reveals that Jüttner, like Becher, was holding a stash of 163,000 Swiss Francs promised for "humanitarian purposes."
A pattern emerges: The Indulgence.
The Jewish Agency realized that a dead Nazi pays nothing. A "cleansed" Nazi, grateful for his life, pays a commission. For those who think we are exaggerating, please consider this little fact: In the late 1950s, the West German government had more former Nazis in it than during WWII! Nazi Germany didn't die in May 1945; it was simply rebranded to help the West in the Cold War! Here is an excellent documentary on this little-talked-about subject; trust us. It will be worth your time.
From Suitcases to Submarines: The Macro Deal
Were the British so STUPID as to promise COMPLETE INDEPENDENCE to Palestinians in 1939 (who, of course, "didn't exist") while the Indians had been DREAMING of such a thing for 400 years?The Becher affair was not an isolated incident; it was the proof of concept for the 1952 Reparations Agreement.
In the early 1950s, Israel was insolvent. Ben-Gurion needed German machinery to build the state. To get it, he had to rehabilitate West Germany.
-
The Polls: Ben-Gurion famously cited polling data showing that 60% of West Germans still blamed the Jews for their misfortunes. He knew the "New Germany" was a myth, but he proceeded anyway, see Israel: A History, pp. 147.
-
The Partner: Israel negotiated the reparations with Hans Globke, Adenauer’s Chief of Staff --the man who wrote the legal commentary on the Nuremberg Race Laws.
-
The Deal: Just as Kastner sold an indulgence to Becher for $55,000, Israel sold an indulgence to West Germany for 3.45 billion Deutsche Marks. , which was equivalent to $845 million. To put things into perspective, this massive amount account up to 60% of what was allocated for West Germany from the Marshal Plan, which was $1.4 billion. In other words, the US Congress bailed out Israel by directly authorizing it!
Now, allow these numbers to sink in for a minute and reflect on how such a massive liquidity injection was funneled into a nation of less than a million, while Germany had over 50 million! Don't you love capitalism when it works like this?
Fake Valor: Why Did Zionist Jews Hoist Nazis Flag on Their Ships in the 1930s?In a nutshell, the Germans bailed out Zionism at least twice. Once in 1933, when Adolf Hitler bailed out the Jewish Agency (JA) (when it was almost bankrupt due to the Great Depression) by signing the Haavara Agreement between Nazi Germany and JA, and the other one, Haavara V2.0, was twenty years later, in the early 1950s, when Israel faced a sever liquidy crisis! During the Great Depression, American Jewry cut off funding to Zionists, and that resulted in 3/4th of the Jewish Agency being in deficit, see The Transfer Agreement, pp. 90. If you care, we have addressed this subject in depth in another section.
The Zionist Version Of Lebensraum: A Map Of The Great IsraelIn this regard, it is worth contemplating what the former speaker of Knesset (Abraham Burg) has concluded on this matter:
"It turns out that before the Nazis started to slaughter Europe’s Jews, they enabled us to build the foundations of our state-to-be", Israel. After the Jewish head was decapitated, and our limbs cut offin terrible suffering. This very foundation absorbed the emaciated surviving remnants of European Jewry. After Israel was born in 1948, the German reparations and compensation agreement of 1952 helped the state regenerate itself. Israel absorbed new immigrants and rehabilitated the war refugees, in effect, resurrecting a new Israeli nation that is essentially different from the sum of the ragtag Jewish refugees. (Abraham Burg, pp. 73-4)
It should be noted that the 1952 German repartitions deal was only the first installment. The second and final one came in after the invasion of Lebanon in 1982, when the Israeli economy faced a high level of inflation due to the 1982 War.
David Ben-Gurion envisioned that Nazis' Nuremberg Race Laws would become the LEVER that would end up creating the "Jewish state," but how? Click the image for the details
If someone told you that David Ben-Gurion foresaw twenty years earlier how Jewish pain and suffering would become the LEVER that would create the "Jewish state", of course, you would call him/her a liar and an antisemitic? Well, hang on to your seat. That is exactly how the founding father of the "Jewish state", Ben-Gurion, coined it. Actually, he repeated it often during the height of the calamity.
Operation Business Friend: The Nuclear Connection
The relationship went deeper than cash. Reports indicate a secret 1960 agreement codenamed "Aktion Geschäftsfreund" (Operation Business Friend), where West Germany secretly funneled 500 million Deutsche Marks to Israel. Ostensibly for developing the Negev, these funds are widely suspected to have financed the Dimona nuclear reactor.
This evolved into the modern supply of Dolphin-class submarines --vessels capable of carrying nuclear warheads-- which Germany continues to heavily subsidize. The "Indulgence" didn't just buy German rehabilitation; it bought the hardware for Israel's ultimate survival.
Israel effectively stopped hunting Nazis in Germany during the 1950s. Silence was part of the contract. The "Kastner Train" was just the first shipment in a trade relationship where Jewish blood was converted into German goods, laundering the conscience of a nation in record time.
The $55,000 Becher paid was not restitution. It was a bribe. And the Jewish Agency took it, marking the moment
Related Links
Menu
Fake Valor: Jewish-Brigade, Italy April - 1945: The Impostering Hero, see me while I bomb Nazis. We wonder: were any similar selfies taken at the al-Alamein meat grinder?
Fake Valor: Why did two of Israel's future PMs, Menachem Begin and Yitzhak Shamir, bomb WWII war efforts while their families were being gassed in Poland?
David Ben-Gurion's Response to the British Kindertransport a month after Kristallnacht: NY Times, July 12th, 1987, citing Ben-Gurion's official biographers showing how much he "cared" about Europe's Jews who saved themselves by immigrating to countries other than Palestine!
SS Patria sinking in Haifa port, November 25, 1940
Were the British so STUPID as to promise COMPLETE INDEPENDENCE to Palestinians in 1939 (who, of course, "didn't exist") while the Indians had been DREAMING of such a thing for 400 years?
NY Times Magazine, April 18, 1982: Zionist leaders admitted there wasn't enough bandwidth to fight the White Paper of 1939 and Hitler. Thus, fighting the Nazis was left to the Gentiles so they could focus on defeating the White Paper.
Over 700 Oral History interviews (including 3,500+ hours of recording) can be viewed online.
Post Your Comment
*It should be NOTED that your email address won't be shared, and all communications between members will be routed via the website's mail server.